# Magic Spoon: 13 point Door Gap
- Site: magicspoon.com
- Scanned: 2026-09-08
- Scan type: Basic scan
- Business type: ecommerce
- Report: https://www.seconddoor.io/r/magicspoon-eg7van
- Scanner version: 16
A browser-blocking homepage prevents assistant shopping, though product pages and feeds are readable.
## Scores
| Measure | Score |
| --- | --- |
| Humans | 71/100 (4/4 dimensions) |
| Agents | 58/100 (6/6 dimensions) |
| Composite | 65/100 |
| Door Gap | 13 points |
The human score is the mean of the measured human dimensions, the agent score the mean of the measured agent dimensions, and the Door Gap the difference between them.
## What the machine actually did
The agent got through 11 of 17 requests, but could not find a contact route for machines. It came up empty on 5 other checks too.
- ok      reach the site at all
- ok      find out whether machines are welcome
- ok      ask whether the door opens for requests carrying the AI crawlers' names
- ok      read the site's own guide for language models
- ok      find out what pages exist
- missing find a contact route for machines
- missing find a published agent interface
- missing find an agent plugin manifest
- missing find out whether verified agents are recognised
- ok      read the homepage as data rather than as a page
- missing find a machine readable API spec
- missing read the developer documentation
- ok      read the prices without running JavaScript
- ok      read the product catalogue as data
- ok      read a product page as data
- ok      read the returns and shipping terms
- ok      walk the way a visitor would, to a signup form or a product
## Top issues
1. **Product pages do not publish return or shipping terms in structured data, forcing agents to scrape policy pages as text.** (commercial_rails)
2. **A real browser cannot load the homepage, blocking assistant shopping at the entry point.** (machine_discoverability)
3. **No API documentation or developer guide exists to explain how to use the /products.json feed or integrate with the store.** (programmatic_onboarding)
The evidence and the recommended fix for each are on the report page: https://www.seconddoor.io/r/magicspoon-eg7van
## Files generated from this scan
- **Let verified assistants through** at `notes`, 1 hour, developer. Verify: The next scan opens the homepage and the key pages in a real browser and under the search crawler names, and every one is served.
- **Product markup for Variety 4 - 16 Cereal Treats (4 Boxes)** at `/products/new-variety-4-16-cereal-treats-4-boxes`, 30 minutes, developer. Verify: The next scan reads price, currency and availability in the Product markup of at least one product page, with the structured price matching the catalogue feed.
- **Product markup for Variety 6 - 24 Cereal Treats (6 Boxes)** at `/products/new-variety-6-24-cereal-treats-6-boxes`, 30 minutes, developer. Verify: The next scan reads price, currency and availability in the Product markup of at least one product page, with the structured price matching the catalogue feed.
- **Product markup for Classics Bundle - Chocolate Peanut Butter, Marshmallow, Salted Caramel - TTS** at `/products/vb-treat-3p-choco-peanut-butter-1-marshmallow-1-saltedcaramel-1-tts`, 30 minutes, developer. Verify: The next scan reads price, currency and availability in the Product markup of at least one product page, with the structured price matching the catalogue feed.
- **Product markup snippet for every product page** at `snippets/seconddoor-product-jsonld.liquid`, 30 minutes, developer. Verify: The next scan reads price, currency and availability in the Product markup of every product page it samples, with the structured price matching the catalogue feed.
- **Put Okendo reviews in the page** at `notes`, 10 minutes, no developer needed. Verify: The next scan finds review text in the server HTML of a product page.
- **robots.txt rules for AI crawlers** at `/robots.txt`, 10 minutes, no developer needed. Verify: The next scan reads robots.txt and finds every search and agent crawler allowed, none of them kept off product or pricing paths.
- **Return policy and shipping structured data** at `product page`, 30 minutes, developer. Verify: The next scan reads a MerchantReturnPolicy on the product pages, and OfferShippingDetails when the shipping node was published.
- **Link the policy pages from the product page** at `notes`, 30 minutes, no developer needed. Verify: The next scan finds the returns and shipping policy pages linked from a product page.
- **Variants missing a GTIN or a brand** at `catalog-identifiers.csv`, 5 minutes, no developer needed. Verify: The next scan reads the catalogue feed and finds a valid GTIN on at least nine in ten variants and a brand on at least nine in ten products.
- **Organization structured data** at `homepage`, 15 minutes, developer. Verify: The next scan reads Organization and WebSite nodes in the homepage JSON-LD and the structured data check passes.
- **security.txt** at `/.well-known/security.txt`, 10 minutes, no developer needed. Verify: The next scan fetches /.well-known/security.txt as text and the security.txt check passes.
- **Machine interfaces: where you stand** at `notes`, 10 minutes, no developer needed. Verify: The next scan finds the interface you published answering at its well-known path, and that check passes.
Each file is written from what this scan found on the site. The content is in the JSON once the evidence is opened: https://www.seconddoor.io/api/reports/magicspoon-eg7van
## The agent door
- **machine_discoverability** 83/100. Robots.txt allows all declared AI crawlers by name, llms.txt is published, sitemap lists 88 URLs including products, and product pages carry Product markup with price and currency.
- **programmatic_onboarding** 10/100. No API documentation is linked from the homepage or available at standard paths. The /products.json feed exists and returns 12 products with brand and handle, but no OpenAPI spec, MCP manifest, or developer guide explains how to use it or.
- **pricing_legibility** 88/100. 72 prices appear in the raw HTML of 3 product pages checked, and Product structured data on each carries price in USD and availability. The visible price ($45) matches the structured price, so an agent can read cost without JavaScript or.
- **agent_aware_instrumentation** 22/100. No MCP manifest exists at any of the 3 standard paths checked. The /products.json catalogue feed is open and returns products with brand, but no manifest, plugin definition, or checkout protocol tells an agent how to complete a purchase or.
- **machine_fetchable_trust** 65/100. No security.txt file is published. The returns policy and shipping policy both read as plain text at their policy URLs and are linked from product pages, so trust signals exist but are not centralized or machine-readable.
- **commercial_rails** 78/100. Product markup carries price, currency, identifier, brand, and a 4.6 aggregate rating over 3533 reviews. The catalogue feed includes brand on each product. Returns and shipping policies read as text.
## The human door
- **steps_to_first_value** 95/100. A product with price ($45) and an add-to-cart control is reachable in 2 steps from the homepage. No variant selection is required on the product checked, and Shop Pay and PayPal wallets are accepted, so a buyer can reach checkout.
- **required_fields** 80/100. The product page does not require an account before adding to cart. No form fields demand input before purchase, and 2 express wallets (Shop Pay, PayPal) skip the form entirely, so a guest can buy without providing any data.
- **verification_walls** 75/100. No sign-in requirement appears on the product page or cart. Guest checkout is available, so a shopper can proceed to payment without creating an account or verifying an email.
- **error_recovery** 35/100. Of 3 inputs on the product page, 0 carry validation rules or constraints. 14 live regions and 1 inline error container are present in the markup, but no input validation attributes were found, so error messages may not appear until form.
---
Scored by SecondDoor. Method: https://www.seconddoor.io/methodology
Scan another site: https://www.seconddoor.io
Rate an issue or this report: POST https://www.seconddoor.io/api/feedback, or the rate_fix tool on https://www.seconddoor.io/api/mcp