{"slug":"magicspoon-seeck3","companyName":"Magic Spoon","domain":"magicspoon.com","url":"https://magicspoon.com","headline":"A Shopify storefront that blocks real browsers from loading the homepage, cutting off assistant shopping despite publishing agent protocols.","compositeScore":51,"humanScore":0,"agentScore":51,"doorGap":0,"humanMeasured":0,"agentMeasured":6,"percentile":null,"humanPercentile":null,"agentPercentile":null,"isPartial":true,"depth":"free","siteClass":"unknown","scannerVersion":13,"scannedAt":"2026-09-08T16:13:19.364Z","unlocked":false,"mission":{"steps":[{"url":"https://magicspoon.com","outcome":"ok","purpose":"reach the site at all"},{"url":"https://magicspoon.com/robots.txt","outcome":"ok","purpose":"find out whether machines are welcome"},{"url":"https://magicspoon.com","outcome":"ok","purpose":"ask whether the door opens for requests carrying the AI crawlers' names"},{"url":"https://magicspoon.com/llms.txt","outcome":"ok","purpose":"read the site's own guide for language models"},{"url":"https://magicspoon.com/sitemap.xml","outcome":"ok","purpose":"find out what pages exist"},{"url":"https://magicspoon.com/.well-known/security.txt","outcome":"missing","purpose":"find a contact route for machines"},{"url":"https://magicspoon.com","outcome":"missing","purpose":"find a published agent interface"},{"url":"https://magicspoon.com/.well-known/ai-plugin.json","outcome":"missing","purpose":"find an agent plugin manifest"},{"url":"https://magicspoon.com","outcome":"missing","purpose":"find out whether verified agents are recognised"},{"url":"https://magicspoon.com","outcome":"ok","purpose":"read the homepage as data rather than as a page"},{"url":"https://magicspoon.com","outcome":"missing","purpose":"find a machine readable API spec"},{"url":"https://magicspoon.com","outcome":"missing","purpose":"read the developer documentation"},{"url":"https://magicspoon.com","outcome":"ok","purpose":"read the prices without running JavaScript"},{"url":"https://magicspoon.com","outcome":"ok","purpose":"read the product catalogue as data"},{"url":"https://magicspoon.com","outcome":"ok","purpose":"read a product page as data"},{"url":"https://magicspoon.com","outcome":"ok","purpose":"read the returns and shipping terms"}],"verdict":"The agent got through 10 of 16 requests, but could not find a contact route for machines. It came up empty on 5 other checks too."},"observations":null,"dimensions":[{"key":"machine_discoverability","audience":"agent","score":83,"summary":"No AI crawler is blocked by robots.txt; llms.txt is published; a sitemap lists 89 URLs including 12 products; product pages carry Product schema with price, currency, brand and aggregate rating; the catalogue answers as JSON at.","evidence":{"locked":true,"count":4}},{"key":"programmatic_onboarding","audience":"agent","score":10,"summary":"No API documentation is linked from the homepage or discoverable at standard paths. No OpenAPI spec, developer docs, or integration guide exists. The site publishes a UCP manifest for agent checkout but provides no onboarding path for a.","evidence":{"locked":true,"count":2}},{"key":"pricing_legibility","audience":"agent","score":83,"summary":"Prices appear in raw HTML on the homepage (4 instances) and across 3 product pages checked (47 instances). Product structured data publishes price and currency on every product. An agent can read cost without scraping.","evidence":{"locked":true,"count":2}},{"key":"agent_aware_instrumentation","audience":"agent","score":57,"summary":"A Universal Commerce Protocol manifest version 2026-08-25 is published, declaring 8 capabilities and 3 payment handlers; a storefront MCP endpoint answers agent calls. No MCP manifest exists at standard paths.","evidence":{"locked":true,"count":4}},{"key":"machine_fetchable_trust","audience":"agent","score":65,"summary":"No security.txt is published. The returns policy and shipping policy are readable as text at /policies/refund-policy and /policies/shipping-policy, but neither appears in structured data on product pages.","evidence":{"locked":true,"count":3}},{"key":"commercial_rails","audience":"agent","score":10,"summary":"A UCP manifest is published with 3 payment handlers and 8 shopping capabilities, and a storefront MCP endpoint is live. A real browser cannot load the homepage to initiate a purchase, blocking the human path to checkout.","evidence":{"locked":true,"count":4}},{"key":"steps_to_first_value","audience":"human","score":null,"summary":"Could not verify: this scan did not reach the pages that would show it.","evidence":{"locked":true,"count":0}},{"key":"required_fields","audience":"human","score":null,"summary":"Could not verify: this scan did not reach the pages that would show it.","evidence":{"locked":true,"count":0}},{"key":"verification_walls","audience":"human","score":null,"summary":"Could not verify: this scan did not reach the pages that would show it.","evidence":{"locked":true,"count":0}},{"key":"error_recovery","audience":"human","score":null,"summary":"Could not verify: this scan did not reach the pages that would show it.","evidence":{"locked":true,"count":0}}],"issues":[{"rank":1,"title":"Reviews load from Okendo by script, so a client that reads raw HTML sees the products without a single review.","dimensionKey":"pricing_legibility","evidence":{"locked":true,"count":1},"fix":null},{"rank":2,"title":"Return and shipping policies are not published in structured data on product pages, forcing agents to scrape text or miss critical fulfillment details.","dimensionKey":"machine_fetchable_trust","evidence":{"locked":true,"count":3},"fix":null},{"rank":3,"title":"No API documentation or developer onboarding exists, leaving the published UCP manifest undiscoverable and unusable.","dimensionKey":"programmatic_onboarding","evidence":{"locked":true,"count":3},"fix":null}],"fixArtifacts":{"locked":true,"count":13,"summaries":[{"id":"bot_wall_guidance:notes","kind":"bot_wall_guidance","title":"Let verified assistants through","path":"notes","effort":{"minutes":60,"role":"developer"},"outcome":{"dimension":"machine_discoverability","external":["Assistant shopping and search crawlers reach the product, pricing and policy pages a buyer asks about."]}},{"id":"robots_search_bots:robots-txt","kind":"robots_search_bots","title":"robots.txt rules for AI crawlers","path":"/robots.txt","effort":{"minutes":10,"role":"owner"},"outcome":{"dimension":"machine_discoverability","external":["The assistants' search crawlers read and cite the site to buyers; training stays the owner's decision."]}},{"id":"product_jsonld:products-fg-treat-4p-cookies-cream-40g","kind":"product_jsonld","title":"Product markup for Cookies & Cream Treats","path":"/products/fg-treat-4p-cookies-cream-40g","effort":{"minutes":30,"role":"developer"},"outcome":{"dimension":"pricing_legibility","external":["Assistants read price, availability and identifiers from every sampled product page."]}},{"id":"product_jsonld:products-new-variety-4-16-cereal-treats-4-boxes","kind":"product_jsonld","title":"Product markup for Variety 4 - 16 Cereal Treats (4 Boxes)","path":"/products/new-variety-4-16-cereal-treats-4-boxes","effort":{"minutes":30,"role":"developer"},"outcome":{"dimension":"pricing_legibility","external":["Assistants read price, availability and identifiers from every sampled product page."]}},{"id":"product_jsonld:products-new-variety-6-24-cereal-treats-6-boxes","kind":"product_jsonld","title":"Product markup for Variety 6 - 24 Cereal Treats (6 Boxes)","path":"/products/new-variety-6-24-cereal-treats-6-boxes","effort":{"minutes":30,"role":"developer"},"outcome":{"dimension":"pricing_legibility","external":["Assistants read price, availability and identifiers from every sampled product page."]}},{"id":"product_jsonld_liquid:snippets-seconddoor-product-jsonld-liquid","kind":"product_jsonld_liquid","title":"Product markup snippet for every product page","path":"snippets/seconddoor-product-jsonld.liquid","effort":{"minutes":30,"role":"developer"},"outcome":{"dimension":"pricing_legibility","external":["Every Shopify product page carries complete Product markup, not only the sampled ones."]}},{"id":"review_schema_vendor:notes","kind":"review_schema_vendor","title":"Put Okendo reviews in the page","path":"notes","effort":{"minutes":10,"role":"owner"},"outcome":{"dimension":"machine_discoverability","external":["Review text and ratings reach crawlers that do not run the review widget's script."]}},{"id":"merchant_policy_jsonld:product-page","kind":"merchant_policy_jsonld","title":"Return policy and shipping structured data","path":"product page","effort":{"minutes":30,"role":"developer"},"outcome":{"dimension":"machine_fetchable_trust","external":["Assistants read the return window and shipping terms from structured data."]}},{"id":"policy_pages_text:notes","kind":"policy_pages_text","title":"Link the policy pages from the product page","path":"notes","effort":{"minutes":30,"role":"owner"},"outcome":{"dimension":"machine_fetchable_trust","external":["Returns and shipping pages read as text and are linked from every product page."]}},{"id":"catalog_identifiers:catalog-identifiers-csv","kind":"catalog_identifiers","title":"Variants missing a GTIN or a brand","path":"catalog-identifiers.csv","effort":{"minutes":5,"role":"owner"},"outcome":{"dimension":"machine_discoverability","external":["Feed listings stop being rejected for a missing brand or GTIN."]}},{"id":"organization_jsonld:homepage","kind":"organization_jsonld","title":"Organization structured data","path":"homepage","effort":{"minutes":15,"role":"developer"},"outcome":{"dimension":"machine_discoverability","external":["Search and assistant crawlers read the company entity from the homepage rather than inferring it."]}},{"id":"interfaces_note:notes","kind":"interfaces_note","title":"Machine interfaces: where you stand","path":"notes","effort":{"minutes":10,"role":"owner"},"outcome":{"dimension":"agent_aware_instrumentation","external":["The developer surface is built in an order where every published pointer answers."]}},{"id":"security_txt:well-known-security-txt","kind":"security_txt","title":"security.txt","path":"/.well-known/security.txt","effort":{"minutes":10,"role":"owner"},"outcome":{"dimension":"machine_fetchable_trust","external":["Researchers and automated scanners find a disclosure address instead of guessing one."]}}]},"feedback":{"endpoint":"/api/feedback","mcpTool":"rate_fix","targets":[{"type":"report","key":"report"},{"type":"dimension","dimensionKey":"machine_discoverability","key":"dimension:machine_discoverability"},{"type":"dimension","dimensionKey":"programmatic_onboarding","key":"dimension:programmatic_onboarding"},{"type":"dimension","dimensionKey":"pricing_legibility","key":"dimension:pricing_legibility"},{"type":"dimension","dimensionKey":"agent_aware_instrumentation","key":"dimension:agent_aware_instrumentation"},{"type":"dimension","dimensionKey":"machine_fetchable_trust","key":"dimension:machine_fetchable_trust"},{"type":"dimension","dimensionKey":"commercial_rails","key":"dimension:commercial_rails"},{"type":"dimension","dimensionKey":"steps_to_first_value","key":"dimension:steps_to_first_value"},{"type":"dimension","dimensionKey":"required_fields","key":"dimension:required_fields"},{"type":"dimension","dimensionKey":"verification_walls","key":"dimension:verification_walls"},{"type":"dimension","dimensionKey":"error_recovery","key":"dimension:error_recovery"},{"type":"issue","dimensionKey":"pricing_legibility","checkId":"product_pages","key":"issue:pricing_legibility:product_pages"},{"type":"issue","dimensionKey":"machine_fetchable_trust","checkId":"security_txt","key":"issue:machine_fetchable_trust:security_txt"},{"type":"issue","dimensionKey":"programmatic_onboarding","checkId":null,"key":"issue:programmatic_onboarding:-"}]}}